(no subject)

[labellementeuse]

Hi folks! Question: how do we feel about the use of "I" in humanities papers? Someone (not a prof) has just read an essay for me and edited out every use of the first person. I understand that this is a valid response, but I personally find it frustrating. I think the passive voice is awkward, takes the life out of a text, and furthermore find it a dishonest attempt to obscure the context of the piece and its origin*; I find structures like "The rest of this essay will explore A, B, and C" idiotic. I have read plenty of articles that use "I" in the same way I do. Is this one of those "Do as I say not as I do until you have a PhD and tenure" things? I know it can be used badly, and sometimes I do (and then try to catch it on an editing pass), but I don't think every use of it ever is bad.

*This, if you were wondering, is What Is Wrong With Science Today.

Comments

[aimeesworld.livejournal.com]

I used 'I' in my research essay and my supervisor didn't seem to mind? At least he didn't call me on it and it is all handed in now?

[labellementeuse.livejournal.com]

OR MAYBE HE DID MIND and you'll find that out later!!!

JUST JOKING. Yeah, I have some in my research essay too that Anna hasn't picked up on. I wouldn't worry about it except I have to write two essays for this guy this week, and obviously I don't expect him to mark the first before I give him the second which means I don't have the testing effect - e.g. finding out with the first one what he wants for the second one.